AI Quick Summary

Use a 105-point self-check to find process-safety sections that need attention. The score is an internal prompt, not a validated benchmark or compliance decision.

Your facility has a MIPP, risk assessment, training records, and audit schedule. The harder test is whether those systems change decisions during a plant upset, equipment impairment, rushed shutdown, or late project.
Use this process safety maturity self-assessment to identify areas for follow-up. It is an editorial self-check, not a validated maturity instrument, compliance audit, or determination that a facility is safe. Score each statement from 0 to 3 using evidence available to the team:

  • 0: No system or evidence is demonstrated.
  • 1: A documented system exists, but use is inconsistent.
  • 2: Teams use the system and can show current evidence.
  • 3: Leaders verify effectiveness and improve the system from results.
    Do not award points for a policy alone. Ask for field evidence, recent records, and examples.
    The statements and score bands below are prompts developed for this article. They are not an MHI regulatory scoring system and have not been validated against a representative sample of facilities.

1. Leadership and accountability

Score each statement:

  1. Senior leaders know the site's top major-incident scenarios and critical barriers.
  2. Named managers own process-safety actions, impairments, and overdue assurance work.
  3. Production decisions include process-safety limits and barrier availability.
  4. Leaders visit the field and test whether systems work during real tasks.
  5. The site tracks process-safety performance separately from personal injury performance.
    Section score: /15
    A mature site can explain why it stopped a transfer, delayed a startup, reduced inventory, or cancelled hot work because a barrier was unavailable.

2. Hazard and risk knowledge

  1. HAZOPs, QRAs, BowTies, and scenario registers match the current plant.
  2. Teams review changes, incidents, inspection findings, and new information against the risk picture.
  3. Operators and maintainers can explain the major hazards in their area.
  4. Risk recommendations have clear owners, due dates, and technical closure evidence.
  5. If the establishment is subject to South Africa's MHI Regulations, the duty holder tracks the approved inspection authority risk assessment at intervals not exceeding five years and when the establishment changes.
    Section score: /15
    Check whether the physical plant, P&IDs, procedures, and risk studies agree. A mismatch signals weak control of change.

3. Management of Change and operational readiness

  1. Staff can distinguish replacement in kind from a change requiring review.
  2. The MOC process covers temporary, procedural, software, and organisational changes.
  3. Teams update drawings, procedures, inspection tasks, and training before startup.
  4. PSSR reviews include field verification and clear go or no-go authority.
  5. Temporary changes carry owners, expiry dates, controls, and restoration plans.
    Section score: /15
    Use the Management of Change guide to examine weak points in this section.

4. Operating discipline and control of work

  1. Procedures reflect field equipment and state the response to deviations.
  2. Shift handovers cover inhibited safeguards, abnormal conditions, permits, and temporary changes.
  3. Permit issuers verify isolations and task controls in the field.
  4. The site coordinates simultaneous operations and stops work when conditions change.
  5. Supervisors observe safety-critical tasks and correct system weaknesses.
    Section score: /15
    Review our permit-to-work guide and human factors guide when the site relies on signatures rather than understanding.

5. Asset integrity and barrier assurance

  1. The facility has a current safety-critical equipment register.
  2. Each critical item has a defined function, test, interval, and acceptance criterion.
  3. Inspection plans address credible degradation mechanisms.
  4. Leaders can see overdue critical maintenance, failed tests, and active impairments.
  5. Deferrals include a technical basis, temporary controls, approval, and revised date.
    Section score: /15
    Use the asset integrity guide to review corrosion, inspection, and aging-plant risks.

6. Emergency preparedness

  1. Emergency plans match current scenarios, inventories, layouts, and neighbouring receptors.
  2. Drills test decisions and coordination, not only evacuation time.
  3. The site records lessons, assigns actions, and verifies closure.
  4. Firewater, detection, communications, alarms, and response equipment receive functional tests.
  5. The facility shares relevant information with emergency services and adjacent establishments.
    Section score: /15
    The SANS 1514 emergency-planning guide provides more detail.

7. Learning, competence, and worker participation

  1. Incident investigations identify system causes and verify corrective-action effectiveness.
  2. Near misses and weak signals receive review before a major event occurs.
  3. Competence requirements state the knowledge, skill, and experience needed for each critical role.
  4. Workers participate in risk assessments, procedure design, and improvement work.
  5. The site retains technical knowledge through mentoring, records, and structured handovers.
    Section score: /15
    Training attendance alone does not prove competence. Ask a person to perform or explain the critical task.

Interpret your score

Add the seven section scores for a total out of 105.

Score Interpretation Priority
0 to 35 Many practices need evidence Identify urgent barrier issues and assign accountable owners.
36 to 60 Several systems are documented Check whether people use them in the field and close execution gaps.
61 to 84 Evidence is present across many areas Test weak sections, interaction between controls and action quality.
85 to 105 Strong self-reported coverage Verify the evidence independently and test performance under abnormal conditions.
These bands only organise this article's checklist results. They are not industry benchmarks or maturity ratings. The total helps with orientation; section evidence should drive action. A high total cannot compensate for a weak emergency or asset-integrity control.
The value of a self-check is the discussion it creates between records, field conditions and leadership decisions. The World Steel Association's 2026 data report includes a separate process-safety maturity analysis based on information from 38 member organisations, representing 36.2% of its membership. That industry sample uses its own 17-element model; it is context, not a benchmark for this checklist or an individual South African site.

Turn the assessment into a 90-day plan

Choose no more than five actions. Prioritise:

  1. an impaired or missing barrier for a high-consequence scenario;
  2. an overdue legal or risk-assessment obligation;
  3. a repeated failure across MOC, PTW, inspection, or training;
  4. a gap that prevents leaders from seeing current risk;
  5. one workforce improvement that makes the safe action easier.
    Give each action an owner, due date, completion standard, and effectiveness check. Re-score the relevant section after 90 days.
    The Department of Employment and Labour's March 2026 MHI workshop highlighted plant fitness and performance monitoring. This programme update is not a site-specific compliance finding. A self-check can help a duty holder review whether its process-safety management system works beyond the policy file.
    MMRisk conducts MHI reviews, process-safety audits, BowTie workshops, hazard studies, and bespoke training. Contact MMRisk for an independent maturity assessment or targeted improvement plan.

Related resources

Frequently asked questions

Is this a validated process-safety maturity model?

No. It is an article-level self-check with seven sections and an internal scoring scheme. Do not use its total to certify compliance, compare sites or claim that a facility is safe.

Does a high score prove the site is ready for a major incident?

No. Review the evidence behind each answer and investigate weak sections. A self-reported score cannot establish barrier effectiveness or replace the applicable risk assessment, inspections and assurance work.

How should a site use the results?

Choose a small number of high-consequence gaps, assign owners and due dates, define acceptable closure evidence and check effectiveness. Repeat the relevant section after changes have had time to take effect.

Sources