Learn what consequence modelling can show, which inputs shape the result, and why modelled distances are scenario estimates rather than predictions.
Consequence modelling estimates how a defined hazardous release could affect people, equipment or the surrounding area. A model may estimate thermal radiation from a fire, blast effects from an explosion, or airborne concentrations after a toxic release. The result depends on the scenario, input data, model, endpoint and assumptions; it is not a prediction of what will happen in a real incident.
For South African major hazard installations, Regulation 10 of the Major Hazard Installation Regulations, 2022 requires a risk assessment by an approved inspection authority in accordance with SANS 1461 at intervals not exceeding five years or when the establishment changes. That requirement concerns the risk assessment. The public regulation does not by itself establish that one software product, consequence model or set of numerical harm thresholds is mandatory for every study.
What does a consequence model estimate?
The analyst defines a release scenario and estimates the resulting physical effects using a suitable method. Common scenario families include:
- Fire: a jet fire, pool fire or flash fire following a flammable release.
- Explosion: blast effects from a defined explosion scenario, where the process and surroundings support that scenario.
- Toxic dispersion: concentrations downwind of a toxic release under stated release and weather conditions.
These labels do not establish that a scenario is credible at a particular site. A hazard assessment must identify the substances, equipment, operating conditions and failure paths that support each case.
What information does an analyst need?
The input set depends on the scenario and method. It commonly includes the substance and inventory, equipment and operating conditions, release location and size, release duration, isolation assumptions, weather, terrain, buildings and the effect endpoint being assessed. Site records and process data should be checked with the people responsible for the installation.
The study should state its scenarios, data sources, assumptions, endpoint criteria, model version and limitations. Sensitivity cases can show whether a decision changes when uncertain inputs change. A single contour or distance without those details can give a false sense of precision.
How should we read modelled distances and thresholds?
Read a contour as the modelled extent for a specified endpoint under specified assumptions. It does not mean everyone inside that boundary will experience the same harm, or that people outside it face no risk. Consequence and risk also differ: a consequence result describes an effect for a scenario, while risk assessment considers scenario likelihood as well as consequences, under the applicable method.
Thresholds are not universal constants. The endpoint should match the decision, such as emergency planning, facility siting or assessment of harm, and should come from an identified, applicable technical or regulatory basis. Toxic values such as NIOSH IDLH are exposure and respirator-selection references with a specific purpose; they are not automatically the correct endpoint for every off-site consequence study. The analyst should identify the source, exposure duration and population for any criterion used.
Model results also have uncertainty. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency cautions that its prescribed worst-case assumptions are designed to produce conservative consequence distances, not accurate predictions of actual releases. That is U.S. regulatory guidance, but it illustrates why users must distinguish a required screening case from a site-specific estimate and state the model's intended use.
What can change the result?
Release rate and duration, inventory, weather, terrain, buildings, isolation time, model choice and endpoint can materially affect an estimate. For a toxic plume, wind and atmospheric conditions influence dispersion. For a fire or explosion, the source term, equipment geometry and surroundings shape the effect. Use local, fit-for-purpose data where available and explain how missing data were handled.
Do not compare two model outputs unless their scenarios, endpoints, units and assumptions are sufficiently aligned. Different models can produce different estimates. Record those differences and resolve whether they matter for the decision rather than presenting one distance as exact.
How does consequence modelling fit into a QRA?
Quantitative risk analysis (QRA) combines defined scenarios, their frequencies or likelihoods, consequences and exposed people or assets according to the study method. Consequence modelling can supply the physical-effect or vulnerability part of that work. It is not a QRA by itself, and a contour map alone does not show individual or societal risk.
For a South African MHI assessment, confirm the applicable regulation, SANS 1461 edition and approved inspection authority's scope. The MHI Regulations require an AIA-led risk assessment in accordance with the standard; the detailed standard is not reproduced in the public Gazette. Do not infer detailed modelling requirements from the regulation's title alone.
What should we request in a modelling scope?
Before appointing a consultant, ask for:
- The decision the study must support and the required deliverable.
- Scenario-selection method and the data the facility must provide.
- Model, endpoints, weather cases and assumptions, including uncertainty treatment.
- How results connect to the QRA, emergency planning or design decision.
- Review, approval and revision requirements if site conditions or inputs change.
Cost and delivery time depend on the number and complexity of scenarios, available process and site data, endpoint and reporting needs, and review requirements. Obtain a scoped quotation. This article does not provide verified market rates or a standard turnaround time.
Frequently asked questions
Does the MHI Regulations require consequence modelling software?
Regulation 10 requires an approved inspection authority to carry out the MHI risk assessment in accordance with SANS 1461. The public regulation does not name a software product or prescribe one universal modelling package. Confirm detailed method requirements with the applicable standard and the approved inspection authority.
Are modelled distances predictions of an accident?
No. They are scenario-based estimates conditional on the inputs, endpoint and assumptions. Use them with the study's limitations and intended decision in view.
Is a consequence study the same as a QRA?
No. Consequence modelling estimates effects for defined scenarios. A QRA combines scenarios, likelihoods and consequences under a stated method to assess risk.
How do I compare two modelling proposals?
Compare their scope, scenarios, data requirements, endpoints, assumptions, uncertainty treatment, outputs and review process. A lower fee or a single distance is not enough to show that two scopes are equivalent.
Related resources
- Quantitative Risk Analysis guide
- LPG installation hazards
- Battery energy storage system hazards
- Dangerous goods road and rail risk
Sources
- South African Major Hazard Installation Regulations, 2022, Regulation 10 (South African legal requirement)
- U.S. EPA: Risk Management Program Guidance for Offsite Consequence Analysis (U.S. regulatory modelling guidance; its worst-case rules are not South African requirements)
- NIOSH: Immediately Dangerous to Life or Health (IDLH) (U.S. occupational and respirator-selection reference)
- U.S. EPA: ALOHA software and technical documentation (emergency planning and response tool information)
MMRisk supports MHI risk assessments and related process-safety work. Contact our team to discuss the decision, site data and study scope.