AI Quick Summary

Learn what a QRA can tell a high-hazard site, how it differs from HAZOP, and when South African MHI rules require an AIA risk assessment.

Quantitative Risk Analysis (QRA) uses numerical methods to assess risk from defined major-accident scenarios. Under South Africa's Major Hazard Installation (MHI) Regulations, a duty holder must arrange for an Approved Inspection Authority (AIA) to carry out the risk assessment required by Regulation 10 in accordance with SANS 1461. The assessment is due at intervals not exceeding five years or when there is a change in the establishment. The Department's 2024 explanatory notes describe this assessment as a QRA.
The exact scope depends on the establishment, its hazards and the applicable standard. A QRA supports decisions about risk reduction, emergency arrangements and land use. It does not predict an exact accident date or prove that a facility is risk-free.

What does a QRA assess?

A QRA examines credible major-accident scenarios and estimates their frequency and consequences using quantitative data and models. Depending on the study scope, it may consider toxic releases, fires, explosions, affected populations and risk distribution around a site. The AIA must explain the assumptions, input data, scenario selection and limitations behind its conclusions.
The MHI Regulations require the AIA to report the classification and acceptability of risk and make recommendations, including on emergency procedures, organisational measures and risk reduction. The full SANS 1461 standard contains detailed requirements and is not reproduced here.

QRA and HAZOP answer different questions

Method Main question Typical use
HAZOP How could process deviations occur, what could cause them, and what safeguards are available? Structured hazard identification and review of a process design or operation.
Qualitative risk assessment Which hazards need attention first, given the selected likelihood and consequence method? Screening, prioritisation and review of controls.
QRA What numerical risk results from the defined major-accident scenarios and assumptions? The SANS 1461 MHI risk assessment, and other project decisions where a quantitative study is justified or required.
A QRA does not replace HAZOP or site operating controls. Hazard identification informs the scenarios considered, while the QRA adds quantitative analysis for the purpose and scope of the study.

When is a QRA required for an MHI?

Regulation 10 applies to MHI duty holders. It requires an AIA risk assessment in accordance with SANS 1461 no more than five years apart and when there is a change in the establishment. Regulation 2 and Annexure A determine whether the MHI Regulations apply. Annexure A includes named substances, hazard categories, qualifying quantities, aggregation calculations and a 2% rule with location conditions.
Do not rely on an isolated inventory number from a blog table. Check the current gazetted Annexure A against the maximum quantities and substance classifications at the specific establishment. Where several substances or categories are present, apply the prescribed aggregation rules. An AIA should confirm the classification and required assessment scope.
The Department's 2024 Explanatory Notes explain how it interprets the MHI Regulations and SANS 1461. The Regulations remain the legal text. Other approvals or authorities may require additional risk information for a particular project, but there is no single universal QRA trigger for every non-MHI facility.

What information should a QRA team review?

The AIA will define the required information for the agreed scope. Useful records commonly include:

  • a hazardous-substance inventory with maximum quantities, conditions and classifications;
  • current process flow diagrams, P&IDs and equipment data;
  • a site layout showing equipment, occupancy and relevant neighbouring receptors;
  • operating conditions, safeguards, maintenance and incident information;
  • relevant meteorological, population and land-use data; and
  • previous hazard studies, risk assessments and changes to the establishment.
    If the records are incomplete, the AIA should identify what is missing, how that affects the assessment and what assumptions require confirmation. Do not treat a modelled result as more precise than its source data.

How should teams use the results?

Read the conclusions with the scenario definitions, data and assumptions. Ask which scenarios dominate the reported risk, which safeguards affect the result, what uncertainty remains, and which recommendations need an owner. South African Regulation 22 requires the AIA to provide recommendations on risk reduction and other matters arising from the assessment.
Use the assessment alongside HAZOP, incident learning, asset integrity, emergency planning and change management. Update the risk picture when the establishment changes or when new evidence materially affects the assumptions. A contour or numerical result is one decision input; it does not replace field verification or a competent management decision.

What affects the scope and effort?

The AIA should scope the work from the establishment and the applicable SANS 1461 requirements. Inventory complexity, number of credible scenarios, data quality, neighbouring receptors, changes since the prior study and the need to resolve assumptions can all affect the work. No project-specific fee or completion date can be estimated without reviewing those inputs.
MMRisk supports MHI risk assessments and related process-safety work. Contact MMRisk to discuss the establishment, the applicable assessment cycle and the information available for scoping.

Frequently asked questions

Does a risk matrix replace the MHI QRA?

No. A risk matrix can support screening and prioritisation, but it does not replace the AIA risk assessment required under Regulation 10 for an in-scope MHI duty holder.

Does a QRA replace HAZOP?

No. HAZOP helps identify process deviations and safeguards. QRA evaluates defined major-accident scenarios quantitatively. The methods have different purposes and can inform one another.

Is every QRA result an exact prediction?

No. It is an estimate based on selected scenarios, data, assumptions and methods. The report should explain those inputs and their limitations.

Can a QRA show that a facility is completely safe?

No. It can help assess and reduce risk within its scope. It cannot establish zero risk or replace operational controls, emergency readiness or ongoing review.

Sources

Related resources