AI Quick Summary

Compare qualitative methods and QRA by the question each answers, then check when South African MHI rules require an AIA assessment.

Qualitative and quantitative risk assessments use different methods and answer different questions. A qualitative method helps a team identify hazards and prioritise controls. A Quantitative Risk Assessment (QRA) uses numerical methods to analyse defined scenarios. For an establishment covered by South Africa's Major Hazard Installation Regulations, Regulation 10 requires the duty holder to arrange an AIA risk assessment in accordance with SANS 1461 at intervals not exceeding five years or when the establishment changes.

What is the difference?

Qualitative assessment Quantitative Risk Assessment (QRA)
Main question What can go wrong, why, and what controls are in place? What numerical risk results from the defined scenarios and assumptions?
Common methods HAZID, HAZOP, BowTie review and structured risk matrices Frequency and consequence analysis under the applicable study method
Main evidence Process knowledge, operating experience, workshop findings and control evidence Scenario definitions, inventory, equipment and site data, model inputs and frequency assumptions
Useful for Finding hazards, testing safeguards and prioritising further analysis Assessing defined major-accident scenarios quantitatively for the study purpose
Limit Category labels do not calculate numerical risk Results depend on scope, data, assumptions and method; they do not predict an exact event date
The categories are not interchangeable. HAZOP does not calculate numerical risk, and QRA does not remove the need to identify hazards or manage the controls in the field.

When does South African law require an MHI risk assessment?

For an MHI duty holder, Regulation 10 requires an AIA to conduct the risk assessment in accordance with SANS 1461 no more than five years apart and when the establishment changes. The Department's 2024 Explanatory Notes describe the assessment as a QRA carried out by an AIA.
Regulation 2 and Annexure A determine which establishments fall under the MHI Regulations. Annexure A includes named substances and categories, qualifying quantities, aggregation calculations and a conditional 2% rule. Check the current Gazette and the establishment's maximum inventories; do not use a single threshold value without its category and aggregation context.
This legal duty is specific to in-scope MHI establishments. A QRA may also be requested for a project or approval under other applicable requirements, but the need and scope should be confirmed with the relevant authority and competent AIA. Do not present a HAZID finding, rezoning application or public receptor by itself as a universal legal trigger.

How should a team choose the method?

Start with the decision. Use qualitative methods to identify scenarios, examine causes and safeguards, and decide where more analysis is needed. Use QRA when the applicable legal requirement or project question calls for numerical assessment. For an MHI duty holder, follow the Regulation 10 and SANS 1461 process with an AIA.
Where a QRA is required, keep the scenario assumptions and input data visible. Ask the AIA how uncertainties affect the result and what recommendations require action. Use the findings with HAZOP, maintenance, emergency planning and management of change, not as a substitute for those controls.

Frequently asked questions

Is HAZOP a quantitative risk assessment?

No. HAZOP is a structured hazard-identification method. It can inform the scenarios considered in a QRA, but it does not by itself provide the quantitative assessment required by SANS 1461.

Can a risk matrix replace the MHI QRA?

No. A matrix can help screen and prioritise hazards, but an in-scope MHI duty holder must arrange the risk assessment required under Regulation 10.

Does QRA provide a guaranteed prediction?

No. A QRA estimates risk for defined scenarios using data, assumptions and methods. The report should explain the limits of those estimates.
Read the complete QRA guide or check when a QRA is required. Contact MMRisk to discuss a site-specific assessment.

Sources