Check the inventory, establishment category, assessment scope, consultation, source records, and action tracking before an MHI risk assessment. These preparation points are practical prompts, not a ranked list of industry-wide failure rates.
Before an MHI risk assessment, verify that the inventory, process description, drawings, site layout, and assessment scope describe the establishment as it operates. Under regulation 10, the duty holder must ensure that an Approved Inspection Authority (AIA) carries out the risk assessment in accordance with SANS 1461, after consultation with the relevant health and safety representative or committee.
This is a practical preparation guide, not a ranking of the most frequent industry failures. No facility-specific assessment file or comparative dataset was supplied, so the points below should be used as checks rather than as claims about how often other sites make each mistake.
Updated, 3 November 2026: Removed unsupported claims about hundreds of past assessments, “most common” errors, rejection rates, price bands, and enforcement outcomes. Reframed the advice as verifiable preparation checks under the 2022 Regulations.
1. Starting with an incomplete or stale inventory
Classification under Annexure A depends on dangerous substances, quantities, categories, and the applicable notes and aggregation rules. A list of substances without maximum quantities, mixtures, process inventories, or relevant location information may not support a reliable screen.
Before the assessment, reconcile procurement and stock records with process and storage information. Record the basis for maximum quantities and flag uncertainties for the AIA. Do not copy a threshold from another facility or infer category from the industry name.
2. Using site documents that do not match the plant
Out-of-date process flow diagrams, P&IDs, plot plans, equipment lists, procedures, or emergency contacts can distort the assessment scope. Identify document owner and revision, compare important drawings with current operating conditions, and record known differences. The assessment team should know which documents are preliminary and which are controlled site records.
3. Choosing an AIA without checking the scope
Regulation 10 assigns the risk assessment to an AIA. Before appointment, check current Department approval and the AIA’s scope for the relevant substances or activity. Agree the assessment boundary, input data, methods, deliverables, exclusions, schedule, and any work outside the AIA’s scope in writing. Do not assume that a low quote or a general accreditation covers every MHI activity.
4. Leaving employees and required consultation until late
Regulation 10 requires consultation with the relevant health and safety representative or committee. Inform the representative or committee in writing about assessment arrangements and make the results available for comment. Include people who understand the actual process and its operating conditions when their input is relevant to the assessment.
5. Treating recommendations as a finished assessment
An assessment report and implementation of recommendations are related but distinct work. Maintain an action register that identifies the report reference, site decision, owner, due date, interim controls where applicable, evidence needed for close-out, and any linked change-control process. The duty holder should determine priorities from the actual risk and applicable requirements; a generic article cannot decide whether an operation should continue.
6. Missing the document-specific review trigger
The Regulations do not set one shared review interval for all MHI records. Regulation 10 requires reassessment at intervals not exceeding five years or when there is a change in the establishment. Regulation 11 sets MIPP review at five years or when a change makes the policy inadequate. For a high-hazard establishment, regulation 12 sets Safety Report review every five years, before any establishment change, and after a qualifying process-safety-management-system change.
Keep separate due dates and change triggers for the assessment, MIPP, Safety Report, registration, licence, and emergency plan. Do not treat each item as a five-year assessment.
7. Omitting consultation and public-information records
Regulation 10 includes communication and public participation requirements in specified circumstances, including advertisement and community notices for an establishment erection, an updated risk assessment, or conversion of an existing installation. Confirm which trigger applies and retain the required publication and notice evidence. Ask the relevant local government or AIA about the site-specific process where the scope is unclear.
8. Failing to connect the assessment to emergency arrangements
The on-site emergency plan is governed separately under regulation 15. It must include how employees, visitors, and neighbours will be warned; obtain relevant local-government approval; remain available for use; and be exercised in practice at least annually, with steps to arrange local-government participation. The duty holder must give early warning to affected or interested parties when a major incident is likely to go beyond the establishment boundary. The local government is responsible for the off-site emergency plan under regulation 14.
Check that assessment scenarios and emergency documents describe compatible hazards, contacts, boundaries, and responsibilities. Keep exercise actions and updates traceable to the controlled plan.
A preparation checklist
- Confirm the current inventory, processes, site layout, and relevant establishment changes.
- Record the basis for the Annexure A screen and classification; resolve uncertainties with an AIA.
- Verify the AIA’s current approval and applicable scope.
- Agree assessment boundaries, required information, deliverables, assumptions, and exclusions in writing.
- Notify and consult the relevant health and safety representative or committee as required.
- Identify controlled documents that need review and mark known gaps rather than treating drafts as current.
- Track report findings, responsible owners, decisions, and completion evidence.
- Check applicable review triggers and keep emergency-plan records in a separate schedule.
Frequently asked questions
Who must carry out an MHI risk assessment?
Regulation 10 requires the duty holder to ensure that an AIA carries out the risk assessment in accordance with SANS 1461. The applicable scope and establishment facts should be confirmed with the AIA.
How often must the assessment be repeated?
At intervals not exceeding five years or when there is a change in the establishment. Regulation 10 also requires an updated report to be submitted within 60 days when the assessment is reviewed or revised without an establishment change.
Does every MHI need a MIPP and Safety Report?
No. Regulation 2 excludes low hazard establishments from regulations 11–13 and medium hazard establishments from regulations 12–13. Confirm the classification under Annexure A and the complete applicable duties.
Does this checklist demonstrate compliance?
No. It is a preparation aid. Compliance depends on the site facts, applicable duties, assessment, records, and any actual conditions or directions.
Sources
- Major Hazard Installation Regulations, 2022, regulations 2, 4, 10–15 and Annexure A
- Department explanatory notes, Government Gazette 51628 (2024)