Learn what a location-specific individual-risk contour represents, how it differs from an effect contour and why it does not decide MHI status or land use on its own.
A risk contour joins locations that have the same modelled risk value. A location-specific individual-risk (LSIR) contour summarizes a defined risk measure from a QRA under the study’s scenario, exposure and modelling assumptions. It is not a physical barrier, a prediction for a named person or a universal legal boundary.
Distinguish risk contours from effect contours
A physical-effect contour shows where one modelled event reaches a chosen endpoint, such as a toxic concentration or thermal-radiation level. An LSIR contour combines the assessed scenario frequencies and consequences according to the method used in the QRA. A map legend should identify the metric, units, endpoint, model basis and date.
An LSIR value of 10⁻⁶ per year means the assessment reports a value of one millionth per year at that location under its stated assumptions. It does not mean harm is impossible outside the line or certain inside it. Receptor presence, occupancy, sheltering and other exposure assumptions vary by assessment and must be read from the report.
How to review the map
Check the scenario list, release assumptions, frequency data, weather and terrain inputs, receptor locations, model endpoint and sensitivity analysis. Find out which scenarios dominate the result and whether the map shows individual risk, societal risk or a physical effect. Do not compare two maps unless their metrics, assumptions and scope are compatible.
Societal risk considers the frequency of events that could affect different numbers of people and is often presented as an F–N curve. It answers a different question from an individual-risk contour. Use the metric required by the assessment and decision in front of you.
| Map or metric | What it represents | Typical decision use |
|---|---|---|
| Physical-effect contour | A selected consequence endpoint for a defined scenario | Test exposure, equipment effects or emergency-planning assumptions |
| LSIR contour | Modelled individual risk at locations under stated scenario and exposure assumptions | Compare location-specific individual-risk results with applicable criteria |
| Societal-risk curve | Frequency of events against the number of people affected | Examine potential multiple-fatality events and population exposure |
What South African MHI rules say
Regulation 10 of South Africa’s 2022 MHI Regulations requires an AIA risk assessment in accordance with SANS 1461 at intervals not exceeding five years or when an establishment changes. Regulations 10 and 22 describe the assessment and AIA reporting duties. Regulation 14 links specified local-government development decisions to separation distance and unacceptable risk established through the regulation 10 assessment.
The Regulations do not state that 10⁻⁶ is a universal South African acceptability threshold, that crossing a contour automatically makes a site an MHI, or that one generic contour dictates every land-use decision. The full licensed SANS 1461 text and local decision criteria must be checked for the specific case.
Other jurisdictions use their own criteria. For example, the UK HSE describes its separate land-use planning methodology and consultation-distance contours. Those UK values should not be transferred to South African decisions without an applicable legal or technical basis.
Questions about LSIR and risk contours
Does 10⁻⁶ mean the public is safe outside the line?
No. It is a modelled value at the contour under defined assumptions. Other hazards, endpoints and uncertainties may produce risk outside that line.
Is an LSIR contour the same as a toxic-plume boundary?
No. A toxic-plume boundary maps a concentration endpoint for a scenario. LSIR combines frequencies and consequences using the assessment method.
Does a contour crossing a property boundary determine MHI status?
No. MHI status and legal duties follow applicable statutory criteria and the required assessment. A contour can inform a decision but does not make that decision by itself.